Slipping under my radar, the University of Akron has extended head football coach Terry Bowden's contact for an additional two years. I think that at a time of coaching changes or contract extensions is a good reason to look at the on-field performance of the football team. So here is a look at Akron since Bowden's taking the reigns of the Zips for the 2012 season using the Complex Invasion College Football Production Model.
2013
At the time of Bowden's contract extension, Akron was 4-7 - with the best won-loss record since 2008. Akron's best victory to date was a 16-7 victory over currently ranked #89 Kent State and their worst loss was a 3-43 loss to currently ranked #83 Ohio. As of last weekend, Akron had the #97 ranked team in overall production. On the offensive side of the team, Akron was ranked as the #101 team and on the defensive side Akron was the #78 best defense.
Hence in terms of the Complex Invasion College Football Production Model, Akron is slightly more productive overall this season as compared to where the Zips finished the prior season, but only slightly. Akron's offense has slipped and their defense has improved as compared to the previous season. The Zips have played against a strength of schedule equal to 64.27 as compared to the "league's" strength of schedule (SOS) of 68.20, which is "average" since the Zips SOS is within one standard deviation from the leagues average SOS.
2012
Terry Bowden's first season as the head football coach of the Akron Zips was horrible. The Zips finished 1-11, with their only win over FCS Morgan State. Hence the Zips finished their second straight season without a victory against a FBS opponent. The good news was that Akron had what ended up as the worst team in the FBS - the Massachusetts Minutemen but the bad news is that the Zips were defeated by the worst team in all of the FBS. That said, Akron was not the worst team in the "league". In fact Akron had improved from the prior season in terms of their relative ranking in all of the Football Bowl Subdivision.
Akron finished as the #101 team in overall productivity, even with only one victory. This is a good time to recall that the NCAA FBS Production Model does not use wins and losses to rank teams, nor does it use points scored and points surrendered directly to rank teams. Rather the model looks at factors that allow teams to gain and maintain possession, move the ball forward, scoring efficiency and makes adjustments for teams in different conferences.
Turning back to the Zips on-field performance, we see that Akron had the #87 ranked offense and the #101 ranked defense. Both are improvements over the 2011 season, which if you are an optimist is a good sign. I am an economist, and I am unconvinced that teams (in general) show much production consistency. (Although I have not rolled up my sleeves to date and tested this hypothesis. Sounds like a off-season project). Anyway, the Zips played against an average strength of schedule of 69.00 as compared to the "league" average of 65.53.
Synopsis
Does this nearly two year result warrant a contract extension? Who know, but since Akron is improving in the win-loss column, it looks as if the university administration is at least willing to give Bowden more time to improve the football program. Since I am also unconvinced firing a coach will make teams better (again a hypothesis that I have not empirically tackled) giving Bowden more time seems to be a reasonable strategy.
Saturday, November 30, 2013
Friday, November 29, 2013
Iron Bowl - 2013
For the past few seasons, I have been using the NCAA FBS Production Model to give an overview of the "Iron Bowl" pitting the University of Alabama Crimson Tide and the Auburn University Tigers. At the end of this blog are the links to my Iron Bowl analysis going back to the 2010 season. For the game tomorrow, here is the analysis of how the two teams have fared so far this 2013 season.
The University of Alabama Crimson Tide
As of last weekend, Alabama was 11-0 overall and 7-0 in the SEC. The Crimson Tide's best game to date this season (win over highest ranked Complex Invasion College Football Production Model team) was a 38-17 victory over #16 currently ranked LSU. Yes, Alabama's toughest opponent this season to date was against a team not even in the top 10 in the Complex Invasion College Football Production Model's ranking.
In terms of the Crimson Tide's production on the field, Alabama's defense currently ranks as the #5 defense overall, and the Tides offense is currently ranked as the #9, giving Alabama's the #5 ranked team overall. Alabama has played against a strength of schedule equal to 71.00 which is average as compared to the "league" as a whole.
The Auburn University Tigers
As of last weekend, the Tigers are 10-1 overall and 6-1 in the SEC. The Tigers best game to date this season (win over highest ranked Complex Invasion College Football Production Model team) was a 45-41 victory over currently ranked #23 Texas A&M and their worst (and only) loss was a 21-35 defeat to currently ranked #16 LSU. Yes, Auburn has defeated all the teams that are currently ranked lower in the Complex Invasion College Football Production Model's than Auburn is currently ranked, and lost to the only team that is currently ranked higher than Auburn is currently ranked.
In terms of the Tigers production on the field, Auburn's defense currently ranks as the #55 defense overall, and the Tigers offense is currently ranked as the #14, giving the Tigers the #22 ranked team overall. Auburn has played against a strength of schedule equal to 63.91 which is average as compared to the "league" as a whole.
Previous Iron Bowl Analysis
2012
2011
2010
The University of Alabama Crimson Tide
As of last weekend, Alabama was 11-0 overall and 7-0 in the SEC. The Crimson Tide's best game to date this season (win over highest ranked Complex Invasion College Football Production Model team) was a 38-17 victory over #16 currently ranked LSU. Yes, Alabama's toughest opponent this season to date was against a team not even in the top 10 in the Complex Invasion College Football Production Model's ranking.
In terms of the Crimson Tide's production on the field, Alabama's defense currently ranks as the #5 defense overall, and the Tides offense is currently ranked as the #9, giving Alabama's the #5 ranked team overall. Alabama has played against a strength of schedule equal to 71.00 which is average as compared to the "league" as a whole.
The Auburn University Tigers
As of last weekend, the Tigers are 10-1 overall and 6-1 in the SEC. The Tigers best game to date this season (win over highest ranked Complex Invasion College Football Production Model team) was a 45-41 victory over currently ranked #23 Texas A&M and their worst (and only) loss was a 21-35 defeat to currently ranked #16 LSU. Yes, Auburn has defeated all the teams that are currently ranked lower in the Complex Invasion College Football Production Model's than Auburn is currently ranked, and lost to the only team that is currently ranked higher than Auburn is currently ranked.
In terms of the Tigers production on the field, Auburn's defense currently ranks as the #55 defense overall, and the Tigers offense is currently ranked as the #14, giving the Tigers the #22 ranked team overall. Auburn has played against a strength of schedule equal to 63.91 which is average as compared to the "league" as a whole.
Previous Iron Bowl Analysis
2012
2011
2010
Thursday, November 28, 2013
The Heroes Game: Iowa Nebraska - 2013
Happy Thanksgiving! Tomorrow kicks off with the Iowa - Nebraska game to start the end on the Big Ten regular season. This is the third after Thanksgiving game day for Iowa and Nebraska, and given some interest by readers in this game, let's take a look at how these two teams have fared so far during the 2013 regular season.
The University of Iowa Hawkeyes
As of last weekend, the Hawkeyes are 7-4 overall and 4-3 in the Big Ten. The Hawkeyes best game to date this season (win over highest ranked Complex Invasion College Football Production Model team) was a 24-21 victory over #56 currently ranked Michigan last weekend and their worst loss was a 27-30 defeat to currently ranked #10 Northern Illinois. Yes, all four of the Hawkeyes losses have been to teams that are currently ranked in the Complex Invasion College Football Production Model's top 10!
In terms of the Hawkeyes production on the field, the Hawkeye's defense currently ranks as the #17 defense overall, and the Hawkeyes offense is currently ranked as the #73, giving the Hawk's the #50 ranked team overall. Iowa has played against a strength of schedule equal to 63.09 which is average as compared to the "league" as a whole.
The University of Nebraska Cornhuskers
As of last weekend, the Cornhuskers are 8-3 overall and 5-2 in the Big Ten. The Cornhuskers best game to date this season (win over highest ranked Complex Invasion College Football Production Model team) was also a victory over #56 currently ranked Michigan and their worst loss was a 23-34 defeat to currently ranked #67 Minnesota. Nebraka's other two losses have been to teams that are currently ranked in the Complex Invasion College Football Production Model's top 25%.
In terms of the Cornhuskers production on the field, Nebraska's defense currently ranks as the #56 defense overall, and the Cornhuskers offense is currently ranked as the #43, giving the Husker's the #43 ranked team overall. Nebraska has played against a strength of schedule equal to 77.18 which is average as compared to the "league" as a whole.
The University of Iowa Hawkeyes
As of last weekend, the Hawkeyes are 7-4 overall and 4-3 in the Big Ten. The Hawkeyes best game to date this season (win over highest ranked Complex Invasion College Football Production Model team) was a 24-21 victory over #56 currently ranked Michigan last weekend and their worst loss was a 27-30 defeat to currently ranked #10 Northern Illinois. Yes, all four of the Hawkeyes losses have been to teams that are currently ranked in the Complex Invasion College Football Production Model's top 10!
In terms of the Hawkeyes production on the field, the Hawkeye's defense currently ranks as the #17 defense overall, and the Hawkeyes offense is currently ranked as the #73, giving the Hawk's the #50 ranked team overall. Iowa has played against a strength of schedule equal to 63.09 which is average as compared to the "league" as a whole.
The University of Nebraska Cornhuskers
As of last weekend, the Cornhuskers are 8-3 overall and 5-2 in the Big Ten. The Cornhuskers best game to date this season (win over highest ranked Complex Invasion College Football Production Model team) was also a victory over #56 currently ranked Michigan and their worst loss was a 23-34 defeat to currently ranked #67 Minnesota. Nebraka's other two losses have been to teams that are currently ranked in the Complex Invasion College Football Production Model's top 25%.
In terms of the Cornhuskers production on the field, Nebraska's defense currently ranks as the #56 defense overall, and the Cornhuskers offense is currently ranked as the #43, giving the Husker's the #43 ranked team overall. Nebraska has played against a strength of schedule equal to 77.18 which is average as compared to the "league" as a whole.
Tuesday, November 26, 2013
NCAA Athletic Department Spending
Last week I talked to a reporter (Josh O'Leary) for the Iowa City Press Citizen about NCAA athletic department capital spending - focusing on buildings and grounds expenditures. While Mr. O'Leary did a very good job, I thought that I would also share some things that did not make the article.
Using the data from USA Today's NCAA financial department database for the 2006 to 2011 academic years, I find that athletic department spending by Big Ten athletic departments on Buildings and Grounds is statistically different (and higher) for all of the other twenty-nine conferences except for the ACC, Big 12, Pac 12 (now) and SEC during the 2006 to 2009 seasons and for the 2010 and 2011 years is statistically different (and higher) for all the twenty-nine conferences except the ACC, Big 12 and SEC. Hence, Big Ten schools have some of the highest average expenditures on buildings and grounds as a conference.
Additionally, I said that there are "haves and have not's" among NCAA athletic departments. To back that statement up, I note that the degree of building and grounds expenditures is highly unequal. As a comparison group, I looked at income inequality as measure by the Gini coefficient, building and grounds expenditures are more unequal than any of the nations that the World Bank reports from 2009. The highest (most unequal) was South Africa in 2009 at 63.1. For all six years, NCAA athletic department expenditures on building and grounds had a Gini coefficient at a minimum of 72.6, which is more unequal than one of nations with the most unequally distribution of income.
Using the data from USA Today's NCAA financial department database for the 2006 to 2011 academic years, I find that athletic department spending by Big Ten athletic departments on Buildings and Grounds is statistically different (and higher) for all of the other twenty-nine conferences except for the ACC, Big 12, Pac 12 (now) and SEC during the 2006 to 2009 seasons and for the 2010 and 2011 years is statistically different (and higher) for all the twenty-nine conferences except the ACC, Big 12 and SEC. Hence, Big Ten schools have some of the highest average expenditures on buildings and grounds as a conference.
Additionally, I said that there are "haves and have not's" among NCAA athletic departments. To back that statement up, I note that the degree of building and grounds expenditures is highly unequal. As a comparison group, I looked at income inequality as measure by the Gini coefficient, building and grounds expenditures are more unequal than any of the nations that the World Bank reports from 2009. The highest (most unequal) was South Africa in 2009 at 63.1. For all six years, NCAA athletic department expenditures on building and grounds had a Gini coefficient at a minimum of 72.6, which is more unequal than one of nations with the most unequally distribution of income.
Monday, November 25, 2013
2013 NCAA FBS Top 25 Ranking for Week 13
The top team has not changed from last week, nor has the second team (Baylor) even though they lost their first game of the season to Oklahoma State on Saturday. The reason is that Baylor's cumulative total offense and defense still are better than other teams in the FBS using the Complex Invasion College Football Production Model with the stats from College Football Stats. So listed below are the top teams in terms of on-field productivity.
Previous Top 25 Ranks for 2013
2013 NCAA FBS Top 25 Ranking for Week 12
2013 NCAA FBS Top 25 Ranking for Week 11
2013 NCAA FBS Top 25 Ranking for Week 10
2013 NCAA FBS Top 25 Ranking for Week 9
2013 NCAA FBS Top 25 Ranking for Week 8
2013 NCAA FBS Top 25 Ranking for Week 7
2013 NCAA FBS Top 25 Ranking for Week 6
2013 NCAA FBS Top 25 Ranking for Week 5
2013 NCAA FBS Top 25 Ranking for Week 4
2013 NCAA FBS Top 25 Ranking for Week 3
2013 NCAA FBS Top 25 Ranking for Week 2
| Rank | Team |
| 1 | Florida State |
| 2 | Baylor |
| 3 | Oregon |
| 4 | Louisville |
| 5 | Alabama |
| 6 | Ohio State |
| 7 | Wisconsin |
| 8 | Michigan State |
| 9 | Missouri |
| 10 | Northern Illinois |
| 11 | Oklahoma State |
| 12 | Clemson |
| 13 | Marshall |
| 14 | Fresno State |
| 15 | Washington |
| 16 | LSU |
| 17 | Bowling Green |
| 18 | East Carolina |
| 19 | Arizona State |
| 20 | Utah State |
| 21 | Cincinnati |
| 22 | Auburn |
| 23 | Texas A&M |
| 24 | Ball State |
| 25 | Houston |
Previous Top 25 Ranks for 2013
2013 NCAA FBS Top 25 Ranking for Week 12
2013 NCAA FBS Top 25 Ranking for Week 11
2013 NCAA FBS Top 25 Ranking for Week 10
2013 NCAA FBS Top 25 Ranking for Week 9
2013 NCAA FBS Top 25 Ranking for Week 8
2013 NCAA FBS Top 25 Ranking for Week 7
2013 NCAA FBS Top 25 Ranking for Week 6
2013 NCAA FBS Top 25 Ranking for Week 5
2013 NCAA FBS Top 25 Ranking for Week 4
2013 NCAA FBS Top 25 Ranking for Week 3
2013 NCAA FBS Top 25 Ranking for Week 2
Sunday, November 24, 2013
Friday, November 22, 2013
Mike Leach Contract Extension
ESPN reports that Washington State has extended head football coach Mike Leach's contract through 2018. So this is a great time to look at the Washington State program with head football coach Mike Leach at the helm. As a point of reference for those that are interested, I have previously analyzed Washington State under former head football coach Paul Wulff. Below is a chart with the teams total rank, offense rank, defense rank and the worst team rank (which WSU was in both 2008 and 2009) based on the Complex Invasion College Football Production Model. After the chart is a more details about the Washington State University Cougars football team since 2008.
2013
Currently Washington State's record is 5-5 with their best win (win over highest currently ranked opponent) was a 10-7 victory over currently #34 ranked USC. WSU's worst game (loss to the lowest currently ranked opponent) was a 17-55 loss to currently #39 ranked Stanford. In fact all five losses are to teams ranked in the top third of the NCAA Football Bowl Subdivision teams. Hence, Washington State beats teams that they should (Southern Utah, Idaho and California) and some they should not (USC and Arizona) - which makes Washington State an interesting team to watch for in terms of productivity over the next few years given Leach's contract extension. The Cougars are currently ranked as the #86 team in overall productivity with the #71 ranked offense and the #96 ranked defense. WSU has played against a strength of schedule (SOS) of 54.90 which is "tougher" than the average schedule to date for the "league" to date. A teams SOS is "tougher" if it is between one and two standard deviations lower than the average "league" SOS, which is currently the case.
2012
Mike Leach's first season as head football coach of the Washington State Cougars resulted in a 3-9 record. Washington State defeated in-state rival #59 ranked Washington 31-28 and was their best victory of the season. The Cougars worst game was a 34-35 loss to #123 ranked University of Colorado. WSU was the #113 ranked team in terms of overall productivity with again the #117 ranked offense and the #89 ranked defense against an average SOS.
2013
Currently Washington State's record is 5-5 with their best win (win over highest currently ranked opponent) was a 10-7 victory over currently #34 ranked USC. WSU's worst game (loss to the lowest currently ranked opponent) was a 17-55 loss to currently #39 ranked Stanford. In fact all five losses are to teams ranked in the top third of the NCAA Football Bowl Subdivision teams. Hence, Washington State beats teams that they should (Southern Utah, Idaho and California) and some they should not (USC and Arizona) - which makes Washington State an interesting team to watch for in terms of productivity over the next few years given Leach's contract extension. The Cougars are currently ranked as the #86 team in overall productivity with the #71 ranked offense and the #96 ranked defense. WSU has played against a strength of schedule (SOS) of 54.90 which is "tougher" than the average schedule to date for the "league" to date. A teams SOS is "tougher" if it is between one and two standard deviations lower than the average "league" SOS, which is currently the case.
2012
Mike Leach's first season as head football coach of the Washington State Cougars resulted in a 3-9 record. Washington State defeated in-state rival #59 ranked Washington 31-28 and was their best victory of the season. The Cougars worst game was a 34-35 loss to #123 ranked University of Colorado. WSU was the #113 ranked team in terms of overall productivity with again the #117 ranked offense and the #89 ranked defense against an average SOS.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)