Has Wisconsin Been Over-Rated?

I saw this today:

Wisconsin doing what Wisconsin does. Why so much love at the start of every season. I will never understand. Their style no longer works.. Better luck next time. Don't worry Badger fans you will be back in the top 10 at the start of next year.

— David Greene (@greene427622) October 27, 2018

So has Wisconsin been over-rated?  Using the Complex Invasion College Football Production Model from the data provided from www.cfbstats.com, I looked at the Badgers production since 2008 and I must respectfully disagree with Mr. Greene.

This is one of the more consistent football teams over this time period, as you can see below.