The Most Consistently Excellent NHL Goalie: Patrick Roy

One thing the data reveals about NHL goalies is that most NHL goalies are consistently inconsistent overall.  But not all are.  Now I want to turn to looking at the NHL goalies that are consistently consistent.  How do measure it?  I propose the following:  for an individual season, each NHL goalies performance using WAA is "graded" as follows: if they are in the top 20% of all NHL goalies for that season, they get an A, if they are in the next 20%, they get a B, and so on.  Then an NHL goalie is consistent if they maintain their grade from one season to another.  But I only am interested in the highest level of consistent performance, so I only count NHL goalies that from one season to another are among the top 20% of NHL goalies from the 1955/56 season to the 2019/20 season.  Thus, they have to be consecutively in the top 20% of NHL goalies for each season to be counted on the list.

The most consistently excellent NHL goalie performance over their career was by Patrick Roy.

Here are the Top 10 Consistently Excellent NHL Goalies

1. Patrick Roy (16):  1986/87-2002/03
2. Tony Esposito (11):  1969/70-1980/81
3. Billy Smith (9):  1974/74-1983/84
-. Dominic Hasek (9):  1992/92-2001/02
5. Glenn Resche (7):  1974/75-1981/1982
-. Henrik Lundquist (7):  2008/09-2015/16
-. Roberto Luongo (7):  2000/01-2008/09
8. Felix Potvin (5):  1991/92-1996/97
-. Jean-Sebastien Giguere (5): 2001/02-2007/08
-. Tomas Vokum (5):  2005/06-2010/11