Monday, November 18, 2013

2013 NCAA FBS Top 25 Ranking for Week 12

We have a new most productive team this week, with Florida State now ranked as the most productive team in the Football Bowl Subdivision, jumping over Baylor which has moved down to #2.  Here is the list of the top 25 using the Complex Invasion College Football Production Model.  Data from www.cfbstats.com.


Rank Team
1 Florida State
2 Baylor
3 Oregon
4 Louisville
5 Ohio State
6 Wisconsin
7 Alabama
8 Missouri
9 Northern Illinois
10 Texas A&M
11 East Carolina
12 Marshall
13 Michigan State
14 Arizona State
15 Cincinnati
16 Clemson
17 LSU
18 Utah State
19 Oklahoma State
20 Auburn
21 Houston
22 Fresno State
23 Washington
24 Ball State
25 UCLA

Previous Top 25 Ranks for 2013
2013 NCAA FBS Top 25 Ranking for Week 11
2013 NCAA FBS Top 25 Ranking for Week 10
2013 NCAA FBS Top 25 Ranking for Week 9
2013 NCAA FBS Top 25 Ranking for Week 8
2013 NCAA FBS Top 25 Ranking for Week 7
2013 NCAA FBS Top 25 Ranking for Week 6
2013 NCAA FBS Top 25 Ranking for Week 5
2013 NCAA FBS Top 25 Ranking for Week 4
2013 NCAA FBS Top 25 Ranking for Week 3
2013 NCAA FBS Top 25 Ranking for Week 2

Sunday, November 17, 2013

Saturday, November 16, 2013

NCAA Athletic Department Finances

I recently looked at how FBS and non-FBS athletic departments compare in terms of revenue streams and revenue inequality.  To recap - I found that average generated revenues are statistically different and higher at FBS compared to non-FBS athletic departments and that non-generated revenues are not statistically different from each other at FBS and non-FBS athletic departments.

Additionally I looked at revenue inequality among NCAA FBS and non-FBS athletic departments by revenue streams and found that other than ticket sales, FBS athletic departments have greater revenue inequality as compared to non-FBS athletic departments.

I was subsequently asked about the difference between automatically qualifying (AQ) conferences and non-automatic qualifying conferences in the BCS.  Great idea - so here I analyze both differences in revenue and revenue inequality among AQ and non-AQ conferences.

First - are revenue streams different among the AQ and non-AQ conferences?  Short answer is yes.  In fact using the data from USA Today's athletic department database from 2006 to 2011 every revenue category has higher average revenue by AQ athletic departments than non-AQ athletic departments.

Second - are revenues more unequal for AQ than non-AQ athletic departments?  Short answer is that for some yes and others no.  Specifically, AQ athletic department are more unequal for student fee revenue, school fund revenues and other revenues for each of the six years in the USA Today database and AQ athletic departments are more equal for ticket sales, contribution revenues, rights and licensing revenue, total revenue and generated revenues.  Thus other than the two subsidy revenue streams, AQ athletic departments are only more unequal for other revenues.

Friday, November 15, 2013

Baylor Extends Art Briles Contract

ESPN reports that Baylor has finalized head football coach Art Briles' contract for the next ten years.  So this is a good time to look at the Baylor Bears football team since Briles took over the reigns of the Bears in 2008 using the Complex Invasion College Football Production Model. For those interested in how Baylor has ranked during Art Briles tenure, the graph below is a quick look at Baylor's offense, defense and total rankings over the last five plus years.  I have also included what would be the worst ranked team (purple line) for some perspective.


2013 
Currently Baylor is 8-0 with their best win (win over highest currently ranked opponent) over currently #37 ranked Kansas State.  The Bears are currently ranked as the #1 team in overall productivity (and have been nine of the ten weeks I have ranked teams this season) with the #2 ranked offense (slight improvement - read sarcasm) and an immensely improved #4 ranked defense.   

While Baylor gets a lot of attention for their offense, I would like to note how productive the are on defense.  Specifically, in the model that I use, teams that allow their opponents to move the ball, maintain possession and score efficiently are ranked lower on defense.  Given how quickly and how often Baylor scores on offense (currently leads the league in kickoffs to their opponent meaning the defense is on the field often), the Bears defense is phenomenally productive this season.  As you can see in the graph above, defensive performance has been the big problem with Baylor under Briles tenure up to this year.

The knock on Baylor is that they have played against a strength of schedule (SOS) of 86.13 which is "easier" than the average schedule to date for the "league" to date.  A teams SOS is "easier" if it is between one and two standard deviations higher than the average "league" SOS, which is currently the case.  Yet from the model's perspective Baylor is a national championship caliber team.  Of the four regular season games still on Baylor's schedule, they have to play three above average teams in terms of production, with Oklahoma State the toughest challenge for the Bears.  If they can make it though conference play unscathed, Baylor has a legitimate case to play in the "national championship" game in January.

2012
The 2012 Bears are a tale of two teams, one highly productive (offense) and one highly unproductive (defense)   The Bears finished the regular season bowl eligible at 7-5.  Baylor defeated #36 ranked UCLA in the Bridgeport Education Holiday Bowl to finish the season at 8-5 overall.  Baylor was the #49 ranked team in terms of overall productivity with again the #3 ranked offense and the #123 ranked defense against an average SOS. Baylor University's best game was a 52-24 away win over #17 ranked Kansas State and their worst performance was a 21-35 loss to #72 ranked Iowa State.

2011
Baylor University finished the regular season at 9-3 and defeated the #69 ranked University of Washington 67-56 - which seems more like a basketball score than a football score.  Baylor was the #26 ranked NCAA FBS team in overall production, with the #3 ranked offense and the #98 ranked defense.  Baylor's best victory was a 50-48 victory over #9 ranked Texas Christian University and the Bears worst performance was a 35-36 loss to #60 ranked Kansas State.  The Bears played against an average SOS of 62.92 as compared to the "league" SOS of 63.24.

2010
Baylor University finished the regular season bowl eligible at 7-5, but were defeated in the post-season by #18 ranked Illinois.  The Bears were much improved over the previous two seasons and finished as the #51 ranked team in terms of overall productivity; with the #27 ranked offense and the #95 ranked defense.  Baylor University played against a SOS of 60.92, which is "average" (i.e. within one  standard deviation of the "league" average SOS of 63.10).

2009
The Bears against finished the season at 4-8 and bowl ineligible.  Baylor's best game was 40-32 victory over #47 Missouri and their worst loss was to #82 Iowa State all against a SOS that was "tougher" as compared to the average SOS for the "league".  In terms of overall production, Baylor University was the #100 ranked team with the #102 ranked offense and the #68 ranked defense.

2008
In head football coach Art Briles first season at Baylor, the Bears finished the regular season at 4-8 and were bowl ineligible.  Baylor's best game was 38-10 victory over #104 Iowa State (yes all four of their victories were against teams ranked 104 or lower in overall production) and their worst loss was to #40 Nebraska all against a SOS that was "tougher" as compared to the average SOS for the "league".  In terms of overall production, Baylor University was the #50 ranked team with the #46 ranked offense and the #53 ranked defense.

Thursday, November 14, 2013

NBA Payroll and Performance

In our book The Wages of Wins we talk about when performing statistical analysis; for samples, size matters. Specifically, the larger the sample size (more relevant data), the more accurate (smaller the standard error) are the statistical results.  Thus looking at a team over a few games or a league over a couple of years and making definitive statements about the team or the league is a highly dubious endeavor.

How do we come up with such a conclusion?  Here is a guide for further reading:

Why are small sample sizes a problem, and thus need to use a longer time period?
A step-by-step guide on how to perform the payroll and performance analysis.
Why do I use relative payroll (3rd paragraph)?
Why do I use R-squared (or adjusted R-squared) as our measuring stick?

Recently I read the following:  NBA teams in the top 10 of payroll for the past two years have all made the playoffs, and thus the author concludes that the following teams will make the playoffs this year:  Nets, Knicks, Heat, Bulls, Lakers, Raptors, Clippers, Celtics, Thunder and Pacers.  Others looking at on-court performance have left out some of the teams in the payroll top 10 in their predictions.

So payroll "predicts" ten of the sixteen NBA playoff teams.  I think this would be much more convincing if the top 16 teams in terms of payroll made the playoffs for say ten NBA seasons.  That would give much more credibility to this type of statement.  Since this statement only looks at ten of the possible sixteen playoff spots the prediction is only 62.5% accurate - or leaves 37.5% of the playoffs teams unexplained.  For statisticians this is a large error.

So, what I thought I would do was look at the relationship between NBA (relative) payroll and NBA regular season performance.  To do that I need to get NBA payroll data, which is provided at University of Michigan Professor Rodney Fort's website (direct NBA payroll link) and since I was already there, I used his data for NBA regular season winning percentage (direct NBA winning percentage link) to perform this statistical analysis.

Starting with the 1990-91 NBA regular season and finishing with the most completed NBA regular season (2012-2013), performing a linear regression (controlling for heteroskedastity) on the plus side the statistical analysis results in relative payroll to be positive and statistically significant but on the down side reveals that relative payroll and winning percent have almost 11% of common variation, meaning that relative payroll fails to explain about 90% of regular season winning percentage.  Frankly, that is rather poor if you are using payroll to "predict" performance.  If we take a look at the last two NBA seasons (which one was a lockout season), we see that the relationship between relative payroll and regular season winning percent improves to about 23% using adjusted R-squared.  Again, for the last two seasons (one with a lockout) the variation in relative payroll doesn't even explain a quarter of the variation in NBA team winning percent.

If we use a bigger recent sample (five years which covers the 2008-09 to 2012-13 NBA regular seasons) we see that the amount of variation in common between relative payroll and regular season winning percent is still about 23%.  Taking the five years before that (2003-04 to 2007-08 seasons) things are vastly different.  Relative Payroll is statistically insignificant, or in other words, statistically has ZERO impact on winning percent.  Even if you can overlook that the amount of variation in common between the two is 1%.  Hence the relationship between relative payroll and winning percent has improved in the past five years as compared to the previous five year period.  Again, to me not that convincing of a relationship.

As always, the proof is in the pudding - so I will come back to this at the end of the 2013-14 NBA regular season, let's take a look at how well payroll relates to getting into the NBA playoffs.

Wednesday, November 13, 2013

Eastern Michigan University Head Football Coach Relieved of Duties

CBS Sports reports that Eastern Michigan University head football coach Ron English has been relieved of his duties.  This makes the fifth head coaching change so far this season.  Using the Complex Invasion College Football Production Model, let's take a look at the Eastern Michigan University Eagles under former head coach English's tenure.  Here is how the Eagles have ranked since 2009, with more details below this graph.


2013
At the end of the first weekend in November, Eastern Michigan University was 1-8 with their best (and only) win (win over highest currently ranked opponent) over Football Championship Subdivision (FCS) Howard and their worst loss (loss to lowest currently ranked opponent) to #80 ranked Rutgers University.  The Eagles were ranked as the #119 team in overall productivity (out of 125) with the #94 ranked offense and the #123 ranked defense.  The Eagles have played against a strength of schedule (SOS) of 54.22 which was "tougher" than the average schedule to date for the "league".  A teams SOS is "tougher" if it is lower than between one and two standard deviations from the average "league" SOS, which is currently the case.

2012
The Eagles finished 2-10 and were the #116 ranked team in terms of overall productivity with the #110 ranked offense and the #104 ranked defense against an average SOS of 65.75.  Eastern Michigan's best game was a 29-23 away win over #65 ranked Western Michigan and their worst performance was a 14-31 loss to FCS Illinois State.

2011
Eastern Michigan University finished 6-6 and while they had six wins, which normally would make them bowl eligible, two of those victories were against FCS teams and according to NCAA rules only one victory over an FCS school counts towards bowl eligibility, thus EMU did not receive a bowl game invitation.  EMU was the #72 ranked NCAA FBS team in overall production, with the #86 ranked offense and the #54 ranked defense.  Eastern Michigan's best victory was a 14-10 victory over #52 ranked Western Michigan University and the Eagles worst performance was a 31-33 loss to #105 ranked Ball State.  The Eagles played against an easier SOS of 73.67 as compared to the "league" SOS of 63.24.

2010
Eastern Michigan Univeristy finished the regular season at 2-10.  The Eagles were the #117 ranked team in terms of overall productivity; with the #111 ranked offense and the #119 ranked defense.  Eastern Michigan University played against a SOS of 61.42, which is "average" (i.e. within one  standard deviation of the "league" average SOS of 63.10).

2009
The Eagles finished the season at 0-12.  EMU's worst loss was to #110 Ball State all against a SOS that was average as compared to the average SOS for the "league".  In terms of overall production, Eastern Michigan University was the #113 ranked team with the #113 ranked offense and the #101 ranked defense.

2013 NCAA FBS Head Coach Changes
Florida Atlantic and Carl Pelini
Miami of Ohio and Don Treadwell
UConn and Paul Pasqualoni
USC and Lane Kiffen

Monday, November 11, 2013

2013 NCAA FBS Top 25 Ranking for Week 11

The latest NCAA FBS top 25 rankings are now done using the Complex Invasion College Football Production Model.  Baylor regained it's number one ranking from Oregon, which given Baylor's better production on the field as compared to Oregon is no surprise.  Additionally, we see that Alabama has moved up a little and LSU has dropped.

Rank Team
1 Baylor
2 Florida State
3 Oregon
4 Louisville
5 Ohio State
6 Missouri
7 Alabama
8 Texas A&M
9 Northern Illinois
10 Houston
11 Wisconsin
12 LSU
13 Marshall
14 Ball State
15 Washington
16 Fresno State
17 Auburn
18 Utah State
19 Michigan State
20 Arizona State
21 East Carolina
22 Cincinnati
23 Oklahoma State
24 Clemson
25 UCLA

Previous Top 25 Ranks for 2013
2013 NCAA FBS Top 25 Ranking for Week 10
2013 NCAA FBS Top 25 Ranking for Week 9
2013 NCAA FBS Top 25 Ranking for Week 8
2013 NCAA FBS Top 25 Ranking for Week 7
2013 NCAA FBS Top 25 Ranking for Week 6
2013 NCAA FBS Top 25 Ranking for Week 5
2013 NCAA FBS Top 25 Ranking for Week 4
2013 NCAA FBS Top 25 Ranking for Week 3
2013 NCAA FBS Top 25 Ranking for Week 2